everyonedies

Archive 2026-09-24 · 185 entries · 14 chapters

Chapters

Chapter 5

Its Favorite Things

This is the online resource for Chapter 5 of If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies. Some topics we don’t cover on this page, because they’re addressed in the book, include:

In the book, we said that we’ve heard a long list of hopes and copes about superintelligence might benefit humanity in spite of the issues described in Chapter 4. This is the place where we summarize and respond to a long list of them. Many of the answers overlap; two relatively central points we’ll be making are that humans aren’t the most efficient solution to almost any problem, and that AI is unlikely to care about us even a small amount. This is also where we’ll dive into a discussion of AI consciousness and morality.

Questions

  1. Will AI find us useful to keep around?
  2. Will AI treat us as its “parents”?
  3. Won’t AIs need the rule of law?
  4. To a powerful AI, wouldn’t preserving humans be a negligible expense?
  5. Won’t AI find us fascinating or historically important?
  6. Wouldn’t AI recognize our intrinsic moral worth?
  7. Won’t AI want to keep us happy and healthy for the sake of ecological preservation or some similar drive?
  8. But we still have horses. Why wouldn’t AI keep us around?
  9. Won’t AIs care at least a little about humans?
  10. So there’s at least a chance of AI keeping us alive?
  11. If AIs are trained on human data, doesn't that make them likelier to care about human concepts?
  12. Can’t we make the AI promise to be friendly?
  13. What if we make it think it’s in a simulation?
  14. Humans evolved to be selfish, aggressive, and greedy. Won’t AI lack those evolved drives?
  15. Wouldn’t AI only care about the digital realm?
  16. Can the AI be satisfied to the point where it just leaves us alone?
  17. Can we just make it lazy?
  18. Humans tend to get kinder as they get smarter or wiser. Wouldn’t AIs too?
  19. Won’t it realize that its goals are boring?
  20. Why are you imagining a smart AI doing such stupid, trivial things?
  21. Are you just pessimistic?
  22. Would smarter-than-human AI be conscious?
  23. Why don’t you care about the values of any entities other than humans?

Extended Discussion

  1. Taking the AI’s Perspective
  2. Humans Are Almost Never the Most Efficient Solution
  3. Orthogonality: AIs Can Have (Almost) Any Goal
  4. Instrumental Convergence
  5. “Intelligent” (Usually) Implies “Incorrigible”
  6. It’s Hard to Get Robust Laziness
  7. AIs Won’t Keep Their Promises
  8. Effectiveness, Consciousness, and AI Welfare
  9. Losing the Future

Source: ifanyonebuildsit.com/5